Best Pizza in
Wisconsin

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Wisconsin to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
76.5
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Appleton
highest avg. score in Wisconsin
Verified Deliveries
164
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
8
Janesville · Oshkosh · Eau Claire · Waukesha · Appleton · Green Bay · Madison · Milwaukee

State Hall of Fame

Parker John's BBQ & Pizza, Appleton
State Elite
1
Parker John's BBQ & Pizza, Appleton
97.00
Score
2331 E Evergreen Dr, Appleton, WI 54913, USA

The pulled barbecue chicken sandwich arrived warm, its flavor commendable, while the half rack of ribs also proved satisfying. Portion sizes were substantial. The interior decor offered a distinct aesthetic, a departure from more sterile establishments.

Service could be erratic; initial delays in order taking were followed by swift food delivery. One server, Karrie, was noted for her attentive and accommodating approach.

Parker John's BBQ & Pizza, Oshkosh
State Elite
2
Parker John's BBQ & Pizza, Oshkosh
96.00
Score
30 Wisconsin St, Oshkosh, WI 54901, USA

Parker John's BBQ & Pizza offers a casual Oshkosh dining experience. The brisket, ordered as both a sandwich and a salad component, presented a dry texture, with the barbecue sauce struggling to compensate for its lack of moisture. A side of beer cheese, however, proved a notable accompaniment. The establishment also features a lemonade that impressed.

The pizza, a 16-inch offering, arrived at a price point suitable for feeding multiple teenagers. For those seeking a less substantial option, the Sconnie appetizer functioned adequately as a main course. The establishment’s outdoor seating provided a pleasant backdrop.

On the occasion of this visit, the service, as provided by Tonesia, was attentive. This included a willingness to accommodate a canine companion with a table outdoors. The establishment's Friday night fish fry is an all-you-can-eat option.

Parker John's BBQ & Pizza
State Elite
3
Parker John's BBQ & Pizza
95.00
Score
124 Main St, Menasha, WI 54952, USA

Parker John's BBQ & Pizza offers an outdoor deck for diners. The Hawaiian Porker sandwich and BBQ Honey Salad with shredded chicken were noted as delicious. Portions were described as adequate.

A reviewer noted a considerable wait for food, even after seated parties received their meals first. Another experienced a disappointment with a brisket sandwich, citing a small quantity of meat and a bite taken out of waffle fries. A loaded potato pie arrived missing key toppings and barbecue sauce, with the brisket component being disproportionately fatty.

Despite these issues, the barbecue itself received praise for its seasoning and smoking. Servers were found to be fun, friendly, and efficient, contributing to a positive vibe. The Texas-themed decor was appreciated.

Zaronis Pizza
State Elite
4
Zaronis Pizza
94.19
Score
2407 Jackson St, Oshkosh, WI 54901, USA

Zaronis Pizza offers a range of pizzas, including the Zante Fe, noted for its flavor. The establishment also presents mac-n-cheese options, with a potato variation drawing particular approval. Patrons with dietary needs can access gluten-free vegan crusts and cheese for build-your-own selections.

The atmosphere can be quiet, even during peak hours, with early afternoon visits sometimes finding the space sparsely populated. Complimentary breadstick bites were provided during a recent weekday lunch, a gesture appreciated by younger diners.

Service is attentive. One patron reported a particularly pleasant waitress. However, the men's room presented a disarray of broken fixtures and a strong urine odor. A portion of the arcade machines were non-operational, and several others malfunctioned.

Pizza Del Re
State Elite
5
Pizza Del Re
94.00
Score
911 N Hastings Way, Eau Claire, WI 54703, USA

Pizza Del Re offers a cracker-thin crust on its pizzas. The sausage pizza arrives laden with cheese, and the cheese garlic bread, made in-house, evokes a 1990s flavor profile.

A salad bar complements the offerings, though its fullness may vary with customer volume. Some find the crust lacking a desired crispness, and certain pizza varieties, such as the Hawaiian, have been noted for a lack of distinct flavor, overwhelmed by tomato sauce.

The establishment exhibits an older character in its building and maintains a clean, friendly atmosphere. The staff generally engages customers with welcoming interactions.

City Directory