Best Pizza in
North Carolina

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across North Carolina to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
70.4
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Fayetteville
highest avg. score in North Carolina
Verified Deliveries
192
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
8
Gastonia · High Point · Fayetteville · Winston-Salem · Durham · Greensboro · Raleigh · Charlotte

State Hall of Fame

Marco's Pizza
State Elite
1
Marco's Pizza
87.44
Score
1423 W Garrison Blvd, Gastonia, NC 28052, USA

At Marco's Pizza on Garrison Boulevard, the deluxe medium pizza arrived lukewarm. One topping on a small pizza also lacked sufficient heat. A side salad presented brown-edged lettuce. These dishes followed a significant price point, making the overall value questionable.

Melanie provided attentive service, accommodating a misstated pickup time. The order was rectified and prepared within approximately fifteen minutes, a prompt response from management. This efficient handling suggests a capable team when immediate attention is required.

The app presented issues, failing to execute a request for a well-done pizza. The resulting pie was not cooked thoroughly and arrived inadequately cut. This culinary oversight occurred despite clear instructions, indicating a disconnect in preparation standards when delivery is involved.

Sal's Pizzeria
State Elite
2
Sal's Pizzeria
87.05
Score
2211 N New Hope Rd, Gastonia, NC 28054, USA

Sal's Pizzeria presents a New York-style pizza with a crust that is both crunchy and airy. The sauce offers a distinct tomato flavor, harmonizing with the toppings. The pizzeria caters primarily to takeout, though a few indoor and outdoor tables are available.

The establishment is efficient with its lunch specials, delivering orders in ten minutes or less. Customer service is noted as consistently great, even when dealing with difficult-to-find quality options in Gastonia.

For those seeking a well-executed pizza, Sal's crust delivers a notably satisfying crunch. The establishment is worth the drive for those who consider pizza a craft.

Portofino's Italian Restaurant
State Elite
3
Portofino's Italian Restaurant
86.58
Score
3736 E Franklin Blvd, Gastonia, NC 28056, USA

Portofino's Italian Restaurant occupies a narrow space at 3736 E Franklin Blvd. The interior, devoid of televisions, features background music with an Italian character. Staff are welcoming, though one waitress appeared overwhelmed.

The tiramisu provides a sweet conclusion. Pasta and accompanying vegetables were prepared competently, but the pasta lacked distinct flavor and did not appear house-made. Portion sizes are generous.

Despite the initial appearance, the restaurant offers a pleasant atmosphere. It is suitable for gatherings with family or friends.

Pizza Hut
State Elite
4
Pizza Hut
86.00
Score
2521 E Ozark Ave, Gastonia, NC 28054, USA

The glass doors at this Pizza Hut location bear visible fingerprint smudges, and the counter surfaces show an accumulation of crumbs and grease.

A recent order of pizzas and wings experienced an operational discrepancy, with the establishment closed despite the website indicating it was open.

One patron reported receiving cheese sticks that were inconsistently prepared, with one order resembling breadsticks and another precisely cut, alongside an incomplete and damaged apple pie order.

Geraldi's
State Elite
5
Geraldi's
85.57
Score
20 S University Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Geraldi's offers a robust pizza, featuring a satisfying char on the crust. The Italian Geraldi sandwich, notable for its generous size, utilizes house-made mozzarella. Portions across several dishes, including pasta and sandwiches, prove substantial, often exceeding the needs of a single diner.

The establishment, situated off the beaten path, occupies a modest building. Parking availability can be limited. Service staff maintains a professional demeanor throughout the dining experience.

Among the offerings, the spaghetti stands out as well above average. A notable dessert option, the Lemon Berry cake, also warrants attention.

City Directory