Best Pizza in
Nebraska

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Nebraska to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
69.0
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Omaha
highest avg. score in Nebraska
Verified Deliveries
51
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
Lincoln · Omaha

State Hall of Fame

Williamsburg Pizza
State Elite
1
Williamsburg Pizza
86.99
Score
16869 Audrey St, Omaha, NE 68136, USA

Williamsburg Pizza offers a focused selection of New York-style pies. The Cup & Char Grandma, notable for its crisp yet chewy crust, presents a well-balanced distribution of sauce and toppings. The dough's textural contrast between its base and edges is a distinct feature.

Garlic knots are a consistent highlight, their shape prompting comparisons to cinnamon rolls. Meatballs are also offered, holding well for subsequent consumption. The distinction between the square Grandma slices and the round Brooklyn pies is particularly apparent when sampled consecutively, allowing for a clear appreciation of each pie's specific flavor profiles.

The restaurant is located at 16869 Audrey St, Omaha, NE 68136.

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe
State Elite
2
Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe
84.00
Score
1503 Farnam St, Omaha, NE 68102, USA

The sandwich arrived with a singular, forlorn pepper. Orders placed via third-party delivery platforms present a potential labyrinth of customer service issues, particularly when the customer's initial order originates from the restaurant's website. This particular experience involved multiple calls to resolve an undelivered order, ultimately resulting in a lengthy wait for a refund and a manager's offer of a complimentary future meal, still requiring the customer to incur the initial delivery and tip costs.

Ingredients were sparse in a sandwich observed to be assembled with haste. Another instance of hurried preparation resulted in a messy presentation and a lack of expected components. The establishment did offer a free replacement sandwich following a DoorDash order discrepancy, an option that was not pursued.

A pork and pepper pizza featured prominently, though its specific name eluded recollection. The visual process of pizza construction offered entertainment, and the seating area was clean. The cost was noted as substantial, exceeding that of some fast-casual competitors, yet the pizza itself was described as delicious, with fresh toppings, a notable sauce, and a crust that balanced softness. The inclusion of a small piece of bread for soup dipping was an unexpected detail.

Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
State Elite
3
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
83.49
Score
4500 S 70th St Suite 106, Lincoln, NE 68516, USA

Papa Murphy's at 4500 S 70th St offers a distinct approach to pizza acquisition. The concept prioritizes customer control, allowing for toppings to be selected and pizzas prepared for baking at a chosen time. This method offers an alternative to immediate consumption, providing a degree of flexibility in meal planning.

The establishment provides a range of salads, notably featuring a mix of greens beyond simple iceberg, and incorporating items like olives, tomatoes, and peppers. For those seeking specific customizations, the option to substitute ingredients, such as olives for tomatoes on the Gourmet Vegetarian pizza, is available. The presence of additional items like herb and cheese blend and pizza cutters near the checkout caters to the take-and-bake model.

Customer interactions at this location are noted for their efficiency, with orders prepared within minutes. Anecdotal evidence points to attentive staff, even during busy periods. This branch also offers gluten-free crusts and a rewards program, alongside weekly promotions.

🍕
State Elite
4
PizzaWest
80.94
Score
12040 McDermott Plz, La Vista, NE 68128, USA

PizzaWest offers a substantial menu, with certain items drawing particular attention. The taco pizza distinguishes itself, as do the hand-breaded mozzarella sticks, though their seasoning can be inconsistent. Marinara sauce, however, earns praise for its flavor. Lunch specials, including the salad bar, provide a well-stocked and varied option, with fresh ingredients.

Service presents a mixed picture. While some staff exhibit attentiveness, such as a server accommodating special requests and diligently refilling condiments, other interactions fall short. Orders for delivery or takeout have repeatedly omitted requested dipping sauces, necessitating a return trip to the restaurant. This pattern extends to receiving the wrong condiment entirely.

The atmosphere at PizzaWest is casual, suitable for informal gatherings. Garlic knots are noted as excellent. Some pizzas feature abundant toppings, though crust texture can be dense and doughy. The pizza's red sauce carries a noticeable sweetness, presenting an alternative to other sauces available.

🍕
State Elite
5
House of Pizza
77.35
Score
721 Sterling Pkwy #600, Lincoln, CA 95648, USA

House of Pizza occupies a somewhat challenging location, with difficult parking contributing to the operational friction. Despite this, the staff maintain a friendly demeanor throughout the ordering and pickup process, ensuring a ready order upon arrival for those who call ahead.

The pizzas here feature an unusually good amount of craft beer on offer. Crusts are cooked with precision, supporting generous and flavorful toppings.

The combination and Hawaiian pies, for instance, showcase ingredients that contribute to the distinct flavor of each bite, a characteristic noted from the initial taste.

City Directory