Best Pizza in
Missouri

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Missouri to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
72.5
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Columbia
highest avg. score in Missouri
Verified Deliveries
87
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
4
Independence · Columbia · St. Louis · Kansas City

State Hall of Fame

Southside Mafia Pizzeria
State Elite
1
Southside Mafia Pizzeria
87.00
Score
10328 Blue Ridge Blvd, Kansas City, MO 64134, USA

The hand-tossed pizza offered a distinct pesto flavor, though the crust preference proved divisive, perceived as thin by one diner. Cheesy bread provided a predictable, satisfying element.

A meat-heavy pizza featured Canadian bacon, described as nearly invisible. The sauce was notably scarce, a contrast to the generous cheese application.

Garlic parmesan and buffalo wings accompanied a pizza, with readiness noted at fifteen minutes. The staff provided a welcoming demeanor.

Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown
State Elite
2
Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown
86.00
Score
225 S 9th St, Columbia, MO 65201, USA

Shakespeare's Pizza occupies a prominent downtown address, its interior an accumulation of Columbia's past. Rebuilt brick by brick, the space displays a dense arrangement of historical fragments and memorabilia, each turn offering a new visual. The dining room accommodates a significant number of patrons, with televisions broadcasting throughout.

The pizzas arrive generously topped, the crust possessing a discernible crispness. Salads, notably the Louie, are substantial in portion size, though the preparation of the dressing now comes separate from the greens. The beer selection remains cold, served in booths that offer a degree of comfort.

While the establishment is a well-known fixture in the city, the serve-yourself stations can sometimes run low on essential items like forks, requiring patrons to source condiments from other tables. The crust, while crisp, leans towards a thicker style, potentially disappointing those seeking a thinner base.

Pizza Tree
State Elite
3
Pizza Tree
85.49
Score
909 Cherry St, Columbia, MO 65201, USA

Pizza Tree offers creative flavor combinations, such as its signature Kimchi Pie. The pizza features large slices with an impressive crust, notable for its authentic Neapolitan style. The menu extends to vegan options, with the Vegan Pep and Logbro pizzas receiving particular mention.

The establishment prioritizes takeout and delivery, with limited outdoor seating available in an adjacent alley. This setup requires planning for patrons seeking to consume their order on-site. The value proposition is strong, particularly for the quality and inventiveness of the pies.

While generally well-received, one diner noted the tomato vinaigrette on the salad proved unexpectedly spicy. Despite this, the unique savory and umami profile of the Kimchi pizza was a distinct highlight.

G & D Pizzaria
State Elite
4
G & D Pizzaria
85.00
Score
2101 W Broadway, Columbia, MO 65203, USA

The house special arrived loaded with toppings, cooked to a precise finish. Its crust, neither too thick nor too thin, offered a welcome crispness. The Italian sausage, made on-site, provided a distinct flavor.

A small, almost disheartening salad bar charged $10. The Canada bacon pizza surprised with its quality, a flavor profile that proved exceptionally satisfying. Service was efficient, with a friendly cashier noting the transaction.

A small pizza with sausage, and a medium sausage and onion pie together cost $45. The onion, placed beneath the cheese, caused it to slide from each slice, necessitating the use of a fork.

Shakespeare's Pizza - West
State Elite
5
Shakespeare's Pizza - West
84.93
Score
3304 W Broadway Business Park Ct, Columbia, MO 65203, USA

Shakespeare's Pizza - West presents a familiar pizza experience. The crust, though sometimes overcooked, supports a generous distribution of succulent toppings. Leftovers are often packed, indicating sustained appeal.

The restaurant, located in a shopping center, offers ample parking. Inside, children's games and sports on television are present. The establishment has been a fixture in Columbia for decades, with this satellite location upholding its legacy.

Pepsi products are available. The pizza itself draws repeat customers, with its crust and toppings being notable features.

City Directory