HomeIowa

Best Pizza in
Iowa

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across Iowa to find the absolute elite pizza destinations.

Average State Score
77.6
across all ranked restaurants
Top-Rated City
Iowa City
highest avg. score in Iowa
Verified Deliveries
60
restaurants confirmed active
Cities Ranked
3
Council Bluffs · Iowa City · Des Moines

State Hall of Fame

Wig & Pen Pizza Pub - IOWA CITY
State Elite
1
Wig & Pen Pizza Pub - IOWA CITY
96.00
Score
1220 US-6, Iowa City, IA 52246, USA

Wig & Pen offers a deep-dish pizza that rivals Chicago’s offerings. The Crab Rangoon pizza, a house suggestion, arrived loaded with toppings and perfectly baked. Mozzarella sticks, notably large with an impressive cheese pull, are a standout appetizer.

The atmosphere at Wig & Pen provides a comfortable setting for enjoying their fare. Parking presents a challenge during peak hours, yet the wait for the pizzas proved rewarding. The menu extends beyond pizza, featuring a hot club sandwich that is also recommended.

Service was attentive, with a young woman behind the bar noted for her kindness. The establishment is a busy restaurant, with outdoor seating an available option.

Basta Pizzeria Ristorante
State Elite
2
Basta Pizzeria Ristorante
93.54
Score
121 Iowa Ave, Iowa City, IA 52240, USA

Basta Pizzeria Ristorante presents a refined Italian dining experience on Iowa Avenue. Homemade spaghetti noodles accompany a rich Bolognese, and a carrot cake featuring cinnamon and bourbon gelato concludes the meal. The Smoked Salmon Benedetto, served with a notable biscuit, stands out among brunch offerings.

The establishment maintains an elegant yet comfortable atmosphere, complemented by a well-curated wine list. Portions for entrees like the Four Cheese Penne and Chicken Alfredo are generous, often necessitating takeout. The Butternut Squash Ravioli received particular acclaim for its execution.

Service is attentive, and the restaurant offers a pleasant patio for warmer months. The calamari is a frequently cited high point, and the Tiramisu, while satisfying, does not consistently reach the highest praise.

Graze Gourmet To-Go
State Elite
3
Graze Gourmet To-Go
92.12
Score
345 S Dubuque St, Iowa City, IA 52240, USA

Graze Gourmet To-Go offers a selection of prepared meals and pizzas from its Dubuque Street location. The chicken lips, often paired with blue cheese dip, are a notable item. Sourdough pizza crusts, featuring what appear to be quality ingredients, are also available.

The staff consistently provides attentive service, with particular recognition for Lily’s welcoming demeanor and professional attitude. A recent instance involved correcting a pizza order without additional charge, accompanied by complimentary cookies. This level of attentiveness extends to a general friendliness observed during multiple visits.

Graze positions itself as a quicker, potentially healthier lunch alternative. The establishment's approach to customer interaction appears to foster repeat business among those seeking convenient, well-prepared food in the downtown area.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
State Elite
4
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
89.00
Score
3707 Denmark Dr, Council Bluffs, IA 51501, USA

Breadsticks arrived promptly. Minestrone soup offered little distinction, and the Alfredo sauce on seafood fettuccine registered as bland, though its temperature was acceptable.

Staff attentiveness varied. One employee's warmth while offering to-go boxes was noted, contrasting with a general feeling of being rushed. Interactions with the host and server felt transactional.

The dining room noise level was subdued, creating a calm atmosphere even during busy periods. Table turnover appeared efficient.

Fazoli's
State Elite
5
Fazoli's
88.00
Score
3134 Dial Dr, Council Bluffs, IA 51503, USA

The dining area and restrooms maintained a notable level of cleanliness throughout the visit. Staff members, including Tina, ensured food remained hot and fresh, while Jeff and Tina checked on patrons frequently. The speed of service was efficient.

Breadsticks were provided promptly and replenished as needed. Nick, in particular, offered patient assistance with menu choices, answering questions thoroughly.

The location at 3134 Dial Dr presented a tidy environment. Orders placed via the app were accurate and timely.

City Directory