HomeTexasEl Paso

Best Pizza Deliveries
in El Paso

We analyzed hundreds of pizzerias to find the best delivery options in El Paso. Our ranking is based on core quality, reliability, and real customer feedback.

✓ Verified Updated June 2026 · 5 restaurants ranked

Quick Overview

# Business Name Badge Rating Score
1 Speedy's Pizza Monroe
4020 Monroe Ave #6652, El Paso, TX 79930, USA
Value Slice
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
88.10
2 Speedys Pizza
931 Resler Dr Ste 106, El Paso, TX 79912, USA
Pizza and
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
86.87
3 Xtreme Pizza Yarbrough
1212 N Yarbrough Dr #101, El Paso, TX 79925, USA
Value Pricing
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.5
85.00
4 Great American Pizza
2301 N Zaragoza Rd #111, El Paso, TX 79938, USA
Pizza Spot
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.6
83.80
5 Casa Pizza Restaurant
1200 Chelsea St, El Paso, TX 79903, USA
Consistent Crust
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
83.13

Detailed Reviews

Speedy's Pizza Monroe
Value Slice
1
Speedy's Pizza Monroe
88.10
Score
4020 Monroe Ave #6652, El Paso, TX 79930, USA

The crust at Speedy's Pizza Monroe arrives with an uneven char, a consequence of its passage through a conveyor oven. Cheese, a pale mozzarella, stretches thinly. The tomato sauce appears as a sparing application, its flavor unremarkable. A 12-inch pizza registers at a $6.99 price point.

Staff members greet patrons with a smile, demonstrating patience during order selection. The establishment maintains a consistently clean environment. Customers frequently arrive with family to partake in the pizzas.

Choices on offer are presented as one-of-a-kind. Long waits, when they occur, are described as worthwhile.

Speedys Pizza
Pizza and
2
Speedys Pizza
86.87
Score
931 Resler Dr Ste 106, El Paso, TX 79912, USA

The buffalo chicken pizza registers as a distinct offering, its sauce-soaked wings substantial and plentiful. Breadsticks, when prepared correctly, maintain a pleasant crispness, a contrast to the sometimes undercooked crust.

Alex, working the counter alone, manages a steady stream of customers with efficiency. He has been noted for his attentiveness to patrons, ensuring orders are fulfilled promptly.

The establishment's pizza arrives consistently when anticipated, typically within a fifteen-minute window for takeout. Anthony assists customers with phone orders and pickup arrangements.

Xtreme Pizza Yarbrough
Value Pricing
3
Xtreme Pizza Yarbrough
85.00
Score
1212 N Yarbrough Dr #101, El Paso, TX 79925, USA

Xtreme Pizza Yarbrough operates from a nondescript unit in a Yarbrough Drive strip mall. The establishment's pizzas arrive generously topped, with one order noted for substantial pepperoni coverage and a significant amount of cheese. The wings, when prepared correctly, are described as both fresh and tasty.

On occasion, the kitchen falters. An order for pepperoni and buffalo chicken pizzas was delivered with incorrect toppings and a missing buffalo sauce drizzle, leading to a protracted discussion regarding a replacement. Another instance saw wings fried to a point where they were difficult to consume, though prompt correction rectified the issue.

Despite inconsistencies, the pricing is frequently highlighted as a point of value. Patrons have expressed surprise at the quality received relative to the cost, with some returning for subsequent meals within the same week.

Great American Pizza
Pizza Spot
4
Great American Pizza
83.80
Score
2301 N Zaragoza Rd #111, El Paso, TX 79938, USA

Great American Pizza offers a straightforward pizza experience in El Paso. Orders are prepared quickly, with one reviewer noting a pepperoni pizza ready in ten minutes. The crust achieves a good crunch, and toppings, like a generous amount of pepperoni, are present. The flavors meld, and the cheese and crust taste well through to the final slice.

The establishment primarily functions as a walk-in spot. Deals are clearly presented, without complex terms or hidden charges. A manager directly addressed a refund issue for one customer, demonstrating an effort to resolve problems. Boneless garlic parmesan wings were described as remarkable.

However, consistency in preparation can vary. Some pizzas have arrived greasy with a thin crust, lacking adequate cheese or sauce. The air inside has been noted to carry a distinct odor, likened to dirty mop water.

Casa Pizza Restaurant
Consistent Crust
5
Casa Pizza Restaurant
83.13
Score
1200 Chelsea St, El Paso, TX 79903, USA

Casa Pizza offers an expansive menu where individual pizzas arrive promptly, their crusts boasting a consistent crispness. The chicken Parmesan, a generous portion, accommodates a second meal, though its sauce is more sparsely applied than ideal. For those seeking a lighter option, the tossed salad presents a considerable size.

Service at Casa Pizza exhibits a certain variability. While one visit saw a server proactively replace a lemonade with an off-flavor at no cost, another encountered staff unsure of basic pricing or additions. The kitchen's attention to detail also fluctuates; a to-go spaghetti plate, previously lacking sufficient sauce, has since seen a return to its previous, more saucy standard.

The establishment's baklava sample is notably diminutive, a mere two-inch square for its $4 price point. These offerings, however, seem to be outliers in an otherwise capable operation that can deliver a substantial and satisfying meal, particularly when orders are handled with consistent attentiveness.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Restaurant details change — new locations open, others close. If you notice inaccurate information, let us know and we'll review it promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities